ERC-7914: An Interface for Transfer From Native

ERCs
1

Discussion for ERC-7914: An Interface for Transfer From Native

2

Should this requirement be split into two:

SHOULD early return with true when amount == 0 and skip any event emissions […]

Maybe becomes:

SHOULD early return with true when amount == 0 and skip any event emissions. MUST NOT execute any fallback function when amount == 0.

3

You might want to investigate ERC-165 for discovering support for this interface.

4

I don’t think I understand the purpose of the from parameter in transferFromNative. An account can only move its own ether. The rationale given is in the specification:

If from is not address(this) the contract COULD forward the call. Note that specifically parameterizing a from address allows for flexibility, and other types of integrations with this standard.

I don’t think this makes much sense. A delegated approval chain seems unsafe. I suspect this parameter was naively copied over from erc20. Perhaps you could give an example of how this could make sense. Otherwise the from parameter should be removed.