EIP-7805: Committee-based, Fork-choice enforced Inclusion Lists (FOCIL)

The EL part (the execution-spec and also EIP which just copies whatever the execution-spec code is) has a bug which creates a situation where a block and IL pair can be only INVALID or inclusionListSatisfied=false. This is because FOCIL doesn’t consider EIP-7934 which add block-level validation rule: a tx may be “includable”, but a block with the transaction included is INVALID.

We can ask FOCIL to consider this rule, but the implementation is very complex because RLP is variadic length encoding and to compute the precise RLP block size the whole block re-encoding is needed.

The prototype implementation: fix(spec-specs,test-evm-tools,test-specs,test-types,tests): skip IL txs that would exceed the block size limit by chfast · Pull Request #4041 · ethereum/execution-specs · GitHub

I think to be serious about this, we should redesign EIP-7934 and limit the transaction part of the block, not the whole block. EIP-7934 in its current form simply sucks.

1 Like