As a long time holder, former miner of ETH, and non-ETH but seasoned cloud developer and startup founder, seeing this thread is very encouraging and enlightening. It’s a discussion I would love to see more of.
I would like to very directly mention the elephant in the room here - competition and recent price collapse… At the core of it - Ethereum needs to attract developers who are building new L2s or tokenized applications. This means we - as a community - are also in the business of marketing. Solana and XRP are chasing ETH in market cap. If the current trend line of BTC to ETH price holds, it is very possible, perhaps I should say likely that XRP will surpass ETH in market cap. The significance of this should not be dismissed. When this happens, in every chart, in every list, ETH will no longer be next to BTC. In many places ETH will simply no longer be mentioned. It will make marketing to developers much more difficult. Key reasons:
-
Exposure. Marketing is a game of positive and negative spirals. ETH losing its pole position is going to kick off a negative spiral of news, lost interest, influencers, etc. It will essentially say the market has no confidence in ETH.
-
Justification. Even if Ethereum’s technology and dynamics far surpass its rivals (speed, security, decentralization, etc.) - developers must justify their technical choices to product managers, CTOs and VPs. People who view things much more in the abstract. People who want a single slide to summarize anything technical and deal in spreadsheets with basic math. The best technologies don’t win. The best marketed technologies win. Sad fact but a fact. It’s easy to defend a decision when you are picking a market leader. Leaders - in the layman’s mind - are the tokens at the very top of the list.
The absolute most important thing this community can do is to prevent this market cap flip from happening. This probably does not require sudden, massive fees being leveled on L2s, or an immediate, large “wealth transfer” occurring for stakers. But it does require some kind of action for the market to realize that ETH is serious, very serious, about justifying its network value.
Markets are discounting mechanisms driven by sentiment. In the view of the market trend line’s slope (ETH in BTC terms), Ethereum simply does not care about its native asset value or any wealth generation for that matter. Unfortunately, if ETH’s market cap falls below its rivals, it will be taken less seriously as a technology. At least by anyone who makes the final decisions about which blockchain to use at a well funded organization. It will greatly increase the hurdles required for ETH to maintain its dominance as the leading smart contract block chain.
Of course there is a balance here. As is mentioned in various places on this forum, high fees would discourage developers and decision makers also. But there is balance… The network must justify its price.
This is an urgent and timely matter. If the flip happens, it may never flip back. This could create a negative spiral of events which could be unsurmountable in the future - an outcome which could not be coded out of or fixed later with fee changes.
I my view - any value capture related proposal should be significant enough that it sends a clear message to the market that the game has changed: ETH is going to capture more value and defend its network price. It can’t simply be slowly deflationary. Deflation of an asset perceived as worthless, or even trending down, means little for price discovery.
It must somehow reward stakers enough, or promise future rewards, that justify the native asset value. Shooting from the hip here - I’d say we need a staking reward that earns an effective rate at least a few basis points better than the US 10-year. A proposal which adjusted fees, even at a future time, based on a formula pegged to a well known fixed income rate would probably buy time for ETH and get us through this market cycle.