Higher standards for EIPs

[fubuloubu]

Number 1 sounds very similar to this:

Jello Paper as Canonical EVM Spec

Hello all During Devcon 4, there was some discussion about moving the canonical EVM spec to the Jello Paper. I think that this is a fantastic idea. Very few people seem happy with the Yellow Paper as written, and the ambiguous state of maintenance. I am partway through an EVM implementation myself, and have found the Jello Paper to be far superior to the Yellow and Beige Papers. Some of the reasons include: Much clearer Fewer edge cases Took the time to formalize the semantics Executab…

TL;DR is the spec, test suite, and formal semantics are kept together, and each proposal must modify those items in feature branches so they are kept up to date.