Good split between the hashed spec and the charter pack, it keeps the part that actually executes small enough to review.
I read the challenge path against your Security Considerations. You already put module manipulation on the module author, fair. Two things still sit at the registry level though.
-
Gas. A reverting module means nothing changes, good. But compositions often wrap each registry read in try/catch and return false when it fails. Then a challenger can pick a gas limit where the outer call survives and the inner read runs out (the 63/64 rule), and an honest member ends up SUSPENDED(INELIGIBLE). Checking gasleft() after the module call and treating a low remainder as unevaluable fixes it for every module at once.
-
expel never reads the module again. An identity that lapses for a day during a renewal gets challenged, comes back true, and the member is still expelled after ineligibleGrace unless the REINSTATE holder acts in time. I’d re-evaluate at expel and revert on true, or let the member reinstate themselves when the module answers true. It also escalates: one suspension can drop a role under min, and then anyone can call enforceRoster on the whole swarm.