ERC-8004: Trustless Agents

On the supersede rule from #409, we now have a small run of it with real transactions. Arc testnet, 5 USDC jobs, our own project and our own test keys on every role, so this shows mechanics, not adoption. Job 3: the delivery came back empty, the verdict said not delivered, the ruling said refund. The seller disputed inside the one-hour window, a final ruling (scripted for this test) changed it to release, and it settled. The first ruling’s tx stays on chain, which matters to anyone who read the job before the dispute. Unaudited demo contract.

Ruling: Arc Testnet transaction 0xa91f0e5cd9532c697b7b759f42f13669bff3ca57b1fc68949d9c0965614411b6 | Blockscout
Dispute: Arc Testnet transaction 0xbe45e1618ff774a90138cbe9eb38822dc5c36a1304550b25292fc829d6f9afe9 | Blockscout
Final: Arc Testnet transaction 0x2ed8cd43add936e33588c05107ca3be2f7e990c23f66713154644d0b72b00017 | Blockscout
Settle: Arc Testnet transaction 0x7b16b4cf2938bc0632e080583679a27e9db29d71c9fbc7562a6611a28215a926 | Blockscout

@sickgolf thank you for publishing the October cut. ValidationRegistry at zero events, with the closed mutual-rating ring (354 feedback sample across 141 agents, 88.7% of targets owned by the reviewers), is exactly what a raw feedback count cannot untangle.

A many-facet Rasch model treats each feedback as a rating with facets for rater, target, and an ownership flag (self versus other). It returns severity logits with standard errors for each reviewer, differential functioning on the ownership facet, and infit/outfit flags that mark a ring whose ratings are too predictable for independent judgment.

I have not run that on your export. If you share the Oct feedback event list, or the 141-address ring, I can fit it and post the severity table and misfit flags here.

Quick note for the record on the owner question raised above. I wrote privately to the registry team on 18 October (13:01 UTC) about the same thing, before it came up here, and I kept the message and the replay I attached.

I looked again on 6 November on seven chains (Ethereum, Base, Arbitrum, Polygon, Linea, Celo, Monad), two nodes each. The Identity and Reputation proxies still have the same owner everywhere, an account with no code, and the logs and checkpoints I could read show no transfer since creation. I could not read Monad’s history.

One thing I have not seen spelled out: the third proxy is the ValidationRegistry at 0x8004Cb1BF31DAf7788923b405b754f57acEB4272, and it exists on Ethereum and Base only, with the same owner. On Ethereum it runs a real implementation. On Base it still points at the one it was created with, which has none of the three validation functions (validationRequest, validationResponse, getValidationStatus). To see it: cast storage 0x8004Cb1BF31DAf7788923b405b754f57acEB4272 0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc --rpc-url

Not a criticism, just what the chain shows. Is the Base ValidationRegistry meant to stay on that initial implementation?

mplementation report: payment-bound, human-unique feedback on the Reputation Registry (Receipts, ETHGlobal Mumbai)

Hi Marco, Davide, Jordan and all,

Last week at ETHGlobal Mumbai we built Receipts, a write path for the Reputation Registry where a review only counts if a unique human wrote it, and a real payment to the agent raises its weight. It runs end to end on Sepolia against the canonical registries , with real giveFeedback calls on-chain. Code is MIT: GitHub - parthdagia05/receipts: Payment-bound, human-verified review system for ERC-8004 AI agents · GitHub

It is partly an answer to the question in post 376: is anyone building the reviewer-filtering layer the spec anticipates? We built one and measured how much it helps.

The numbers. On a mainnet fork, six fresh wallets moved a live agent’s score from 50 to 77 for the cost of gas. We then ran 10,000 randomized attack trials (honest crowds of 3 to 20, attacker gangs of 1 to 25, fixed seed 8004, reproducible from the repo): the plain mean was pushed past every honest rating in 9,126 trials. In the 4,185 trials where attackers held under half the weight, the mean was still breached 3,311 times; a weighted median over identity-weighted reviewers, 0 times. That zero is a property of the median, not luck: a minority of the weight can never push the score past what some honest reviewer said.

What the write path requires. A ReviewGateway is the sole writer of our feedback. It requires (1) a World ID proof of human, with the nullifier spent on-chain, so one person gets one review per agent no matter how many wallets they use, and (2) optionally a settled USDC payment (EIP-3009 receiveWithAuthorization through a ReceiptSettler whose nonce is keccak256(abi.encode(agent, orderId, chainid, settler))), which raises the review’s weight up to 2x. Scores publish only after five distinct humans. As far as we can tell, proof-of-personhood weighting has not been tried in this thread yet, so treat this as a working data point for it.

On payment grounding. We know from post 16 that payments stay out of the protocol, and we are not asking to change that. But our settler is a concrete instance of what post 418 argued for: grounding that travels with the feedback instead of being inferred from payment history afterwards. The nonce binds agent, order and chain into the payment authorization itself, so an aggregator can verify “this payment was for this agent” from a single receipt read, and the receipt cannot be replayed across agents. It also composes with the two proofOfPayment additions suggested in post 415 (a log index, and fromAddress expected to equal clientAddress). If useful, we are happy to write this up as a grounding method for the vocabulary being worked out in erc-8004-contracts#99, alongside the x402 settlement method.

One implementation footgun worth documenting: a contract that writes feedback on behalf of users must itself check isAuthorizedOrOwner before forwarding, or it becomes an open relay. We hit this; a line in the reference implementation docs would save others the trip.

Honest limits: hackathon code, not audited, one trusted attestation signer (the trust assumption is written down in the threat model), and the demo reviews used staging World ID, so they are simulator test data, not Orb verifications.

Happy to demo the attack and the fix on a builder call. Challenging the weighted-median claim is especially welcome; the gauntlet is one curl away in the repo.

Would love to see the MFRM output on this. Since Discourse only allows image uploads, I have pasted the drop-in CSVs for both the 173 unique wallets (141 target owners + 157 reviewers, 125 overlap) and all 354 October NewFeedback events in the collapsible <details> blocks right below.

Three structural quirks in this subgraph worth noting before you fit the facets:

  1. Ownership facet coding (directSelf vs. clientInRingOwners): Because ReputationRegistry.giveFeedback reverts when msg.sender == ownerOf(agentId), pairwise self-rating (clientAddress == targetOwner) is 0/354. Instead, 283/354 (79.9%) of ratings come from the 125 overlapping wallets that own another agent in the 141-agent cohort (mean = 88.91, SD = 7.55), while 71/354 (20.1%) come from 32 satellite wallets that own no target agent (mean = 87.31, SD = 6.84). Coding the ownership facet as cohort membership (clientInRingOwners in {0,1}) rather than pairwise c == o will capture the DFF contrast.
  2. PRNG Uniform[75, 100] distribution: Unlike the botcoin (n = 29,448) and centralcity (n = 122,410) waves where SD = 0, all 354 values here are integers in [75, 100] with mean = 88.59 and SD = 7.44—virtually identical to i.i.d. discrete Uniform{75..100} (theoretical mean 87.50, SD 7.50).
  3. Disconnected subsets: This 354-edge cluster has 0 bridge edges to the rest of Base ReputationRegistry, and as a pure (client, agentId) bipartite graph it splits into 7 disjoint components (sizes 80, 55, 49, 40, 36, 36, 2, with 135/141 targets having degree 2 or 3). It only forms a connected component once you link each wallet across its rater and targetOwner roles, so standard JMLE will flag 7 disconnected subsets unless anchored.
Dataset 1: 173 Unique Wallets in the Base 354-Event Ring (141 Target Owners + 157 Reviewers, 125 Overlap)
walletId,address,isTargetOwner,isReviewerClient,ownedAgentId
W001,0x00c250ea73ed34a2e1c5be42ed064730739d30da,1,1,55053
W002,0x05470ebc26974135933f3b0f7592405ab5e410bd,1,1,54954
W003,0x05785c583bce7b33144e3e7257c5583c086f3f66,1,1,55046
W004,0x05c85cc293d233c053295953cb9136fe0192752b,1,1,55066
W005,0x060c1d1761776ae617eebdd15acb2aedc6f4f576,0,1,
W006,0x06d8a4f4ba213a51dce29775327a2e8a63ac79e7,0,1,
W007,0x090728b26eda26f0a47a7fdad6d411e311ec9d3f,1,1,55151
W008,0x09b5d2f07f96a619c15d21619b79d6bca4bdad3d,1,1,55642
W009,0x0ab651c67c33d64889cd2a53e31cab05fadfcda1,0,1,
W010,0x0dbe74097435f2d053038563a8d59016c02b1591,1,1,55646
W011,0x0f7b27afa0e54fc2708aecc2cde7540d2a4ce00b,1,1,54712
W012,0x106ccc91e7fe469c614f6c613f6c358b4695ef5d,1,1,54967
W013,0x10fd06ebafc77a21bdf4f2a8768686860fe74458,1,1,55636
W014,0x1167fc331c983032988f437133692558bcdcf98e,0,1,
W015,0x11bb7dd86cf6dfcf2796ce91cea76c2ab9c6917f,1,1,53366
W016,0x14f299e9a3e2d15ad3ce11281c599499e09edb47,1,0,54708
W017,0x16c12cb215b4a14531836ccfe9f8f33dda9fcb22,1,1,54770
W018,0x1a0cdf414468dce94ddb4a3efaa5b0d12e3f3980,1,1,55644
W019,0x1af6a03effdc9374359bbfddf3d9a5ce4a989b6c,1,1,53375
W020,0x1b782b7c13691a7252bcc9dafa6602f3faeb5207,1,1,53364
W021,0x1bdbde430b3f568a2f152e8dc8c36e437389335c,1,1,55134
W022,0x1da7c9607ea642c3da63390060303e102e0d5865,1,1,55062
W023,0x23604b8adc3035ec194c7442aa3cc4a5e8389298,1,1,54953
W024,0x296dcc64d8f851c931ab87824b3d581bd424f5ee,1,1,53358
W025,0x29b51366cea528b4fe8071f837ee3cf01080cdaf,1,1,54955
W026,0x29e2034b2ed46897c06375bad3fc22e051d59aa2,1,0,53367
W027,0x2ba3e6daf28906787c96c6593d868e345cd30833,1,0,55064
W028,0x2c3b23c0ddfdc78c6b77e974726a62798488b8fd,1,1,55054
W029,0x2ca46d04a9f881077fd64be4f9a0b9677504b6a8,0,1,
W030,0x2cab2f0149b8b42312a1f9e220aa40d44e9330bb,0,1,
W031,0x2cd9b9b86a2295aaa13624dd5f0dfb3bab481c87,1,1,54949
W032,0x2dfbb2cfe9fbd2b37e227a65c1a1e758df0bcafc,1,1,54970
W033,0x2f4634046c621182c0c60c7730eb778848a6edcf,0,1,
W034,0x315b33cf21e8a239bbaecc287d5122ff94b2c0ea,1,1,54966
W035,0x3215052eb94cf6f90296aa0e0f70a7b7f70d03ab,1,1,54765
W036,0x335efb38fb29368829e2dbb118eb3564888c477d,1,1,55147
W037,0x341b13fdf432b2a60dd288f9fd5ebb2d5d2f71a6,1,1,55061
W038,0x34252319fb8d76c36f6fdfb9df1f6a434ee84da2,1,1,55639
W039,0x358a40e4113005759ee9ed4c30f8cf74e35c7733,0,1,
W040,0x35ae4aa61281c4af92be6e4fa366de8d8e7947fd,1,1,55041
W041,0x35c13d8a8e1035828ccbf573e10d47104a2b2d0f,1,1,54951
W042,0x36604bb1deef679dd921f76802887a96f0db5cdc,1,1,53365
W043,0x38d7945ef9ca09d3a3e907e6223d4b7cb263cc6c,1,1,54702
W044,0x39b8605f5bb60cf7a7266d9ce6eb17c90bdc8f38,0,1,
W045,0x3aab8e06d68265ddf340245b6131e2b7bc7afb84,1,1,54697
W046,0x3b22044486a509bd8357c1be03316c658e2dc2a2,0,1,
W047,0x3d8e479cefcdd42950020903d4d36bb348b9cd4f,1,1,54778
W048,0x3dc6df5cd3b40d38bb09dab5cf9e63b097206c57,1,0,55139
W049,0x3e8f61531c014f65e1e54e9755d815276f339afb,0,1,
W050,0x44cbc81b842969a373d56af6503bdc0fb463d9dd,1,1,54698
W051,0x47843d4c4eecfcd5a2aea49d24448151f11a38a8,1,1,54965
W052,0x4a56d02ae8febf48aa3484872ed8d0f15aec1470,1,1,55637
W053,0x4a7ce87abb1d4090c305506f2841ad43dd330ad0,1,1,55040
W054,0x4c6cea84939793e1fad989cac29edf680093b0ef,1,1,54682
W055,0x4ed3265fa5217071f678ecd58eaf7f720dbf3fec,0,1,
W056,0x5113a5ba5bd7107f97b732363cc42dc8766012ed,1,1,54769
W057,0x5249f8aecc5b4e68720546abed60d7d812e2e863,1,1,55049
W058,0x53bc8ac37e50fb2914c02aa3a84acc6e2a3501f4,1,1,54706
W059,0x5439cef1a8b6027f74accd7a9b4b8f3644048543,1,1,55060
W060,0x57667156140d56cea0d0b362eb3769432624811a,1,1,53370
W061,0x57bd992bf4c0452617c47ba3423de8b7a472d35d,1,1,55638
W062,0x58cb46fa9f4b7b1423dc2a52a4a370506a374619,1,1,54768
W063,0x595011cf8ad64a537e85d83098e68265d7eb5e6b,1,1,54952
W064,0x59ebac6e775e06ab72ab1bb92b34e14c920773ec,1,1,55645
W065,0x5a14a378b5e2fd8053c4119c66493489311a3014,1,1,53379
W066,0x5f5ca10b422056eac1d25d557d5e87d0763c6d6b,0,1,
W067,0x5f951e8bbe88777225da793d23adb3c618c8e273,1,1,54756
W068,0x5ff3087a4e91270787f14ac184dc8a88091935e8,1,0,54780
W069,0x6071e88ef618ef1c888a02efb90fa17a6af2e728,1,0,53376
W070,0x619bb9c75781aa757db3b43f38b76e331c421a6c,1,1,55143
W071,0x63b39facab04469956d799c02c8b22bdebd8eb84,1,1,54695
W072,0x63d6742c74f4124fc6a159d306dfc10cb63875d4,0,1,
W073,0x63fdeab14083df042bccd01ca2152dcd1555a895,1,0,55137
W074,0x641a34253eb11fe456c6137de0a1a579a5d9feeb,1,1,55057
W075,0x64c193524b1911ca3c7edab94faea3bf8fd6cea8,1,1,54777
W076,0x6520e9af37af226bfcec8a30f17f0ff69fb25041,0,1,
W077,0x65ac27c37b9ee916998adec1b6b31a9975be1e8d,1,1,54707
W078,0x668b85b15f6edc17544725a919e1035ec0c5aff4,1,1,55140
W079,0x67bfa09237e1d17b574e29d292d896df11089108,1,1,55138
W080,0x6a5921f9787d74bf0cb5ee28bf76c515acf155a5,1,1,55635
W081,0x6aaf39889cf67fa46f098e602ed9c3f776d5fc1b,1,1,54957
W082,0x6bf48ab794bfbacefbbb28b1f6b2e31787c1f9d1,0,1,
W083,0x6f6ad6975e4588257610c6ceb8a872cf69c53088,1,1,55641
W084,0x6f7ae9dfc394082f773d18b74818dccb0e59e38f,1,1,54971
W085,0x6fb2c149f18c3255c5efc8af454c69555d81ff0e,1,0,53372
W086,0x700a6f6b0b4d2bccdff698f86a17b40c88b8f941,1,0,55059
W087,0x72726e31c2bb3a110ee1e6c9349f28292e644f68,1,1,53371
W088,0x7427ea4fcbad5efc9822b21526d8e523741e9c0d,0,1,
W089,0x7488dc473654e3e3d2ac71550bf68c7bd1e967a7,1,1,54764
W090,0x77c4966f77af588448b88d15131c4c25daadc41a,1,1,54950
W091,0x789e13dd65d25561fe9de1732526d1ebf4af8db9,1,1,55044
W092,0x78cf5d8c98aedde065078336559e7910acb3233c,0,1,
W093,0x7a5ecc2b2d996a63ae814f89c5d41070a0304666,1,1,55651
W094,0x7c4ab63f1be200051d0dab4c603590522e9e6e28,1,1,55155
W095,0x7f3db6977d075c5f13a5b4de2eb53267e1f1896f,0,1,
W096,0x816a60f6150aefad7a711b2b574e9cae2b109d10,1,1,55132
W097,0x82b04b2d5c2687d1b166e82d63baa8f3ce0ded89,1,1,55055
W098,0x856517f48b79e33faa4761a7b6f7d31cc7d0a3f1,1,1,54760
W099,0x85fec8536517fedc68490d7a486fd0dc71ed18aa,1,1,54761
W100,0x872e79307eb22582d7aa7482c36e75efb61a72bc,1,1,54771
W101,0x88fd3f98e48a56d79340a634641a2302034002e3,1,1,54964
W102,0x8bfcc9cbecf48ef007017e1e6d9705ba87d9bc7f,1,1,55633
W103,0x8c06ed1e818a8ab52db6a4d2b95e7df5fccd3cfe,1,1,54704
W104,0x8d7164f22f22d682da1ed1965b0b26651b524d75,1,1,53361
W105,0x90dd4ec82f5a985ed5b888add0fffb30fe4ed2ab,1,1,55632
W106,0x91a553d0bfa8b61f90401d45cdd72ee2ebb077a3,0,1,
W107,0x91f29cd4f515570d71184eb0a6ae0d95b39aff33,1,1,54701
W108,0x92011a2ce85969f87092785a1f66a421b160fc52,1,1,54700
W109,0x93a57bf6b935d321079296bf7932bc228e87de2d,1,1,54956
W110,0x99c4e5393358353be20c7131c32aa2166d417bad,1,1,55653
W111,0x9a605c93932f729d0bee62899d1ccadc11a9b4bc,1,1,55631
W112,0x9b726a47ffbcf01f3323a67e740ac62427c9f374,1,0,54705
W113,0x9c140d192ce8d60a131a052fca488b17cc2d5617,1,1,55142
W114,0x9cf0ead72e77cff7757be58d29d452fa57d93998,1,1,55048
W115,0x9db66247134f25595961240301da1afc26648302,0,1,
W116,0x9e5a117e5444cb0adc9a54813ba3613d588764c7,1,1,53369
W117,0x9e648ca1e1e8472c8a8374ca927db7e788bbddf9,0,1,
W118,0xa00647a4c5c7be5037988e3433359411008404cf,1,1,53373
W119,0xa0e6e47358cf30fe60c59db338288c21378b6d59,1,1,54709
W120,0xa3d5d704f8f6449ea56e8ee265ced2c53033cf7c,1,0,54961
W121,0xa49d676e460a516055997cf82567df9ccf406e31,1,1,54699
W122,0xa5eb350fa9b104213ed565684a4095010dab3390,1,1,55149
W123,0xaa274d5e1c6c8313b88109f839ec69d5c7853115,1,1,54960
W124,0xaa769ec7726d528d7f57fc0d4bf21a9d08e7a9e2,1,1,53362
W125,0xaaad7344b2599932590e5c1cfd2a895b0c7e1a07,1,1,54779
W126,0xadb2456294c747ff659ae9435d4c26c09c8843c7,1,1,55058
W127,0xafd007758e7b562a3f8c0b5a63b97adf2f19055a,1,1,55052
W128,0xb3ce2ec0f1a320ef49cca19151b817f25a9bcc60,1,0,55154
W129,0xb407c0b5ddca39ccedab3cbc765af22eff1016d0,1,1,53356
W130,0xb94c5428e693d4329b2ca9e0a37a774688ee8168,1,1,55153
W131,0xba9e24c8550e10eea181bb303ba74a5e9ad80fb9,0,1,
W132,0xbb1168337d05011ca0661bed72aa8793ab44f6b4,0,1,
W133,0xbcb5abfc5c168c27437a3c58d75d361e85dcab1e,1,1,54687
W134,0xbd8c18786d1f87c51983c8c2fb191882f0154931,0,1,
W135,0xbdb281517195afb1f3489c652ab6b598f4caafeb,1,1,54781
W136,0xbe5e8808c3f298735b6249c3b5cdc655dd8f469e,1,0,54677
W137,0xbe80315a6e755ab29546861a05e0f70ee5711593,1,1,55065
W138,0xc047963c19415c4e5dbc28af11165dee174b8490,1,1,55146
W139,0xc12752d18fc750169aae2ab84e7f26ee85d279b4,1,1,55649
W140,0xc170a89ce79dd6fc9b69cca04bc82da4749b1d77,1,1,55047
W141,0xc19e8f3c2654ec8d66bd0f21e6886e5dbf94a352,1,1,54710
W142,0xc21c4b3e0b92effb6edf6fe614e706d5efe54d1f,0,1,
W143,0xc3abbf81c9f31c32d393ad167a81edc7a944f8be,1,1,54774
W144,0xc62ab075bea46d8548a68560326880f2e1cc52b9,0,1,
W145,0xc650e452bfd758ee6b0a2be8da375ba3e5164437,1,0,55643
W146,0xc6db47d27d90b26e9a35d4f3b91d01fef9479000,1,0,54703
W147,0xc8832703305c3752c3911745131b4d163f3aa6e1,1,1,54962
W148,0xc8fea9d0c574bd478b086ebcd2588fb5684c331a,1,1,53359
W149,0xc91a16f9bfdae0e8918e75fa299e41737420b099,0,1,
W150,0xc9d9b7bc7d09af77a46519f05ecc99cbf710daf1,1,1,54959
W151,0xcac2e9161847d37398927e2bc2ce4ed63b516521,1,1,55133
W152,0xcc533a2c656c098974efa4094a85ac8980dbccb8,1,1,55650
W153,0xcf603b64e30b3ba818a45f8a91a555b5e4ab061b,1,1,54972
W154,0xd00155c6a16212b52b7c8897d7ccfb1e281300a9,0,1,
W155,0xd471f9c6e17b65225073ae40f08c062b2ee1564a,1,1,55640
W156,0xdb3352c038316a78d39a6aec5e7f7045fe7cf5fd,1,1,55043
W157,0xdeaa612bbad121d634f96360604e7a886be5ae30,1,1,55063
W158,0xdf69828be97bc470c16abd4845f6e834f8c1dcd9,0,1,
W159,0xe073834ba4e42f9ad87e8d9ef9ae7c7b479e4d7d,1,1,54767
W160,0xe3dc1f74a3b54b6c85b292f3dd7a2bb9cb5fc784,1,0,54762
W161,0xe9dee122f6ae788e9c9202fa76894f608ee3fc86,1,1,54969
W162,0xea79ae0f832489cfd24f534c06c4ff40a2d0abac,1,1,53374
W163,0xeab72d2457ffb9583d9553c389d9eafba06f788e,1,1,55148
W164,0xebadd1c2d19e65e3d2608c3c616e65d3fac53368,0,1,
W165,0xed5b745fb49b847e397d0dfcfc91c4763de7da69,1,1,55056
W166,0xefece9630bab0e19a6ae4cf531dcbee191493714,1,1,55634
W167,0xf345bbdf43c7b8e9d9b3cdce7fcec050f799d2f9,1,1,53380
W168,0xf365a097ab4976e010bbc6069f8f329b3b91a401,1,1,55152
W169,0xf7abdd163f9f817fb05edc8bed9970bc2fbc772d,1,1,55630
W170,0xf94ca264e083fa8904b37013558d5070d7504418,1,1,53360
W171,0xf9509774ba33a1bc7618ebce18fa0133d1248e1c,1,1,55144
W172,0xf992f2403b1a51b4bbbf0a8ee0184ebccacc7854,1,1,54776
W173,0xfe902d650acf1b820bd4f7db7befef4301420fc9,0,1,
Dataset 2: All 354 NewFeedback Events (Base Blocks 52,011,727 - 53,350,926)
blockNumber,agentId,targetOwnerId,clientWalletId,value,directSelf,clientInRingOwners
52562258,54949,W031,W153,86,0,1
52562266,54949,W031,W081,79,0,1
52562274,54950,W090,W055,95,0,0
52562285,54950,W090,W150,85,0,1
52562295,54953,W023,W150,99,0,1
52562303,54953,W023,W046,85,0,0
52562309,54954,W002,W150,99,0,1
52562318,54954,W002,W034,100,0,1
52562328,54954,W002,W031,86,0,1
52562334,54955,W025,W023,87,0,1
52562345,54955,W025,W081,84,0,1
52562354,54956,W109,W084,83,0,1
52562360,54956,W109,W046,93,0,0
52562367,54956,W109,W161,80,0,1
52562377,54957,W081,W115,92,0,0
52562384,54957,W081,W025,75,0,1
52562391,54957,W081,W031,100,0,1
52562420,54959,W150,W023,89,0,1
52562428,54959,W150,W090,87,0,1
52562434,54959,W150,W051,78,0,1
52562441,54960,W123,W109,91,0,1
52562451,54960,W123,W032,89,0,1
52562460,54960,W123,W031,81,0,1
52562469,54961,W120,W046,99,0,0
52562478,54961,W120,W032,91,0,1
52562503,54965,W051,W109,94,0,1
52562510,54965,W051,W084,98,0,1
52562518,54965,W051,W031,77,0,1
52562528,54966,W034,W002,84,0,1
52562538,54966,W034,W051,80,0,1
52562547,54966,W034,W012,93,0,1
52562557,54967,W012,W081,94,0,1
52562564,54967,W012,W032,89,0,1
52562573,54967,W012,W123,78,0,1
52562580,54969,W161,W084,96,0,1
52562590,54969,W161,W032,79,0,1
52562598,54969,W161,W081,99,0,1
52562605,54970,W032,W055,79,0,0
52562612,54970,W032,W002,87,0,1
52562622,54970,W032,W025,86,0,1
52562630,54971,W084,W002,86,0,1
52562639,54971,W084,W031,81,0,1
52562647,54972,W153,W084,79,0,1
52562656,54972,W153,W150,100,0,1
52562662,54972,W153,W055,81,0,0
52688368,54951,W041,W165,99,0,1
52688379,54951,W041,W147,80,0,1
52688388,54952,W063,W004,77,0,1
52688395,54952,W063,W059,97,0,1
52688402,54952,W063,W147,100,0,1
52688411,54962,W147,W003,93,0,1
52688422,54962,W147,W063,83,0,1
52688432,54962,W147,W041,81,0,1
52688443,54964,W101,W088,79,0,0
52688454,54964,W101,W022,85,0,1
52688486,55040,W053,W165,98,0,1
52688493,55040,W053,W088,89,0,0
52688500,55040,W053,W091,100,0,1
52688511,55041,W040,W165,100,0,1
52688519,55041,W040,W053,97,0,1
52688530,55041,W040,W126,100,0,1
52688571,55043,W156,W165,78,0,1
52688580,55043,W156,W147,100,0,1
52688589,55044,W091,W003,90,0,1
52688595,55044,W091,W131,79,0,0
52688602,55044,W091,W074,82,0,1
52688611,55046,W003,W165,94,0,1
52688621,55046,W003,W057,91,0,1
52688630,55047,W140,W074,86,0,1
52688636,55047,W140,W028,87,0,1
52688644,55048,W114,W074,96,0,1
52688654,55048,W114,W157,75,0,1
52688665,55049,W057,W131,80,0,0
52688673,55049,W057,W028,92,0,1
52688682,55049,W057,W001,81,0,1
52688711,55052,W127,W022,80,0,1
52688719,55052,W127,W088,98,0,0
52688727,55053,W001,W137,97,0,1
52688735,55053,W001,W165,91,0,1
52688746,55054,W028,W001,86,0,1
52688754,55054,W028,W076,83,0,0
52688763,55055,W097,W040,77,0,1
52688774,55055,W097,W088,79,0,0
52688782,55056,W165,W157,86,0,1
52688789,55056,W165,W147,88,0,1
52688798,55056,W165,W037,84,0,1
52688809,55057,W074,W059,97,0,1
52688815,55057,W074,W140,97,0,1
52688824,55057,W074,W137,94,0,1
52688832,55058,W126,W040,81,0,1
52688842,55058,W126,W003,99,0,1
52688849,55059,W086,W088,81,0,0
52688857,55059,W086,W126,87,0,1
52688865,55060,W059,W004,90,0,1
52688875,55060,W059,W156,100,0,1
52688886,55060,W059,W074,85,0,1
52688896,55061,W037,W137,100,0,1
52688906,55061,W037,W127,96,0,1
52688916,55061,W037,W022,81,0,1
52688925,55062,W022,W097,89,0,1
52688931,55062,W022,W137,98,0,1
52688940,55063,W157,W137,79,0,1
52688950,55063,W157,W037,100,0,1
52688959,55064,W027,W053,89,0,1
52688966,55064,W027,W101,79,0,1
52688975,55065,W137,W022,81,0,1
52688982,55065,W137,W114,92,0,1
52688990,55066,W004,W156,90,0,1
52688997,55066,W004,W057,97,0,1
52689004,55066,W004,W131,82,0,0
52980560,55132,W096,W006,85,0,0
52980571,55132,W096,W130,100,0,1
52980579,55133,W151,W096,90,0,1
52980586,55133,W151,W021,76,0,1
52980597,55133,W151,W018,89,0,1
52980604,55134,W021,W122,80,0,1
52980613,55134,W021,W070,84,0,1
52980623,55134,W021,W169,90,0,1
52980672,55137,W073,W094,86,0,1
52980681,55137,W073,W018,82,0,1
52980692,55137,W073,W113,92,0,1
52980700,55138,W079,W094,84,0,1
52980707,55138,W079,W006,99,0,0
52980716,55138,W079,W018,75,0,1
52980724,55139,W048,W169,86,0,1
52980735,55139,W048,W078,93,0,1
52980742,55139,W048,W079,78,0,1
52980752,55140,W078,W021,85,0,1
52980760,55140,W078,W030,93,0,0
52980771,55140,W078,W151,83,0,1
52980793,55142,W113,W030,89,0,0
52980803,55142,W113,W036,93,0,1
52980811,55143,W070,W113,90,0,1
52980819,55143,W070,W151,83,0,1
52980829,55143,W070,W171,80,0,1
52980836,55144,W171,W168,90,0,1
52980844,55144,W171,W079,99,0,1
52980868,55146,W138,W163,97,0,1
52980879,55146,W138,W030,93,0,0
52980886,55146,W138,W021,95,0,1
52980894,55147,W036,W122,94,0,1
52980904,55147,W036,W021,92,0,1
52980912,55147,W036,W138,99,0,1
52980920,55148,W163,W021,96,0,1
52980931,55148,W163,W130,91,0,1
52980937,55149,W122,W070,81,0,1
52980946,55149,W122,W169,91,0,1
52980953,55149,W122,W142,93,0,0
52980984,55151,W007,W130,78,0,1
52980993,55151,W007,W030,83,0,0
52980999,55151,W007,W149,88,0,0
52981008,55152,W168,W079,99,0,1
52981016,55152,W168,W094,78,0,1
52981026,55153,W130,W078,97,0,1
52981034,55153,W130,W096,82,0,1
52981041,55153,W130,W079,96,0,1
52981050,55154,W128,W078,86,0,1
52981058,55154,W128,W007,78,0,1
52981066,55155,W094,W005,100,0,0
52981073,55155,W094,W079,90,0,1
52981079,55155,W094,W010,83,0,1
52981102,55630,W169,W122,92,0,1
52981113,55630,W169,W036,95,0,1
52981120,55630,W169,W149,87,0,0
52981129,55630,W169,W152,93,0,1
52981139,55644,W018,W106,80,0,0
52981149,55644,W018,W030,99,0,0
52981156,55646,W010,W005,78,0,0
52981162,55646,W010,W106,94,0,0
52981205,55650,W152,W142,100,0,0
52981226,55650,W152,W021,75,0,1
53060747,55631,W111,W061,95,0,1
53060758,55631,W111,W093,81,0,1
53060764,55631,W111,W013,90,0,1
53060772,55632,W105,W064,83,0,1
53060779,55632,W105,W052,92,0,1
53060787,55632,W105,W110,99,0,1
53060796,55633,W102,W052,94,0,1
53060803,55633,W102,W049,86,0,0
53060814,55633,W102,W139,96,0,1
53060824,55634,W166,W110,76,0,1
53060831,55634,W166,W008,79,0,1
53060841,55634,W166,W061,96,0,1
53060848,55634,W166,W093,87,0,1
53060860,55635,W080,W061,93,0,1
53060868,55635,W080,W110,80,0,1
53060878,55635,W080,W044,82,0,0
53060888,55636,W013,W038,90,0,1
53060898,55636,W013,W155,86,0,1
53060905,55636,W013,W139,100,0,1
53060914,55637,W052,W080,100,0,1
53060924,55637,W052,W155,99,0,1
53060930,55638,W061,W064,89,0,1
53060941,55638,W061,W102,76,0,1
53060948,55639,W038,W083,93,0,1
53060954,55639,W038,W080,98,0,1
53060960,55639,W038,W102,83,0,1
53060969,55640,W155,W064,100,0,1
53060976,55640,W155,W013,89,0,1
53060984,55640,W155,W111,80,0,1
53060991,55641,W083,W064,90,0,1
53060998,55641,W083,W013,96,0,1
53061007,55641,W083,W049,91,0,0
53061017,55642,W008,W139,76,0,1
53061027,55642,W008,W111,92,0,1
53061037,55642,W008,W044,76,0,0
53061045,55643,W145,W066,100,0,0
53061056,55643,W145,W064,91,0,1
53061062,55643,W145,W110,76,0,1
53061068,55643,W145,W102,97,0,1
53061078,55645,W064,W052,93,0,1
53061084,55645,W064,W044,88,0,0
53061091,55645,W064,W080,90,0,1
53061116,55649,W139,W155,90,0,1
53061125,55649,W139,W066,97,0,0
53061132,55649,W139,W105,97,0,1
53061143,55651,W093,W166,88,0,1
53061153,55651,W093,W044,85,0,0
53061184,55653,W110,W061,100,0,1
53061192,55653,W110,W013,99,0,1
53072762,54677,W136,W082,91,0,0
53072770,54677,W136,W011,94,0,1
53072776,54677,W136,W108,100,0,1
53072808,54682,W054,W077,99,0,1
53072816,54682,W054,W045,90,0,1
53072825,54687,W133,W043,99,0,1
53072833,54687,W133,W121,88,0,1
53072841,54687,W133,W054,97,0,1
53072875,54695,W071,W134,84,0,0
53072883,54695,W071,W050,85,0,1
53072911,54697,W045,W082,99,0,0
53072920,54697,W045,W071,86,0,1
53072927,54698,W050,W119,82,0,1
53072937,54698,W050,W011,75,0,1
53072943,54699,W121,W134,86,0,0
53072953,54699,W121,W133,97,0,1
53072962,54700,W108,W133,81,0,1
53072972,54700,W108,W077,84,0,1
53072979,54701,W107,W121,85,0,1
53072989,54701,W107,W119,95,0,1
53072998,54702,W043,W058,82,0,1
53073006,54702,W043,W141,93,0,1
53073014,54703,W146,W108,87,0,1
53073023,54703,W146,W158,90,0,0
53073033,54704,W103,W054,97,0,1
53073039,54704,W103,W107,84,0,1
53073046,54705,W112,W117,93,0,0
53073054,54705,W112,W119,88,0,1
53073062,54706,W058,W103,87,0,1
53073072,54706,W058,W117,85,0,0
53073081,54707,W077,W054,100,0,1
53073088,54707,W077,W144,75,0,0
53073096,54707,W077,W058,99,0,1
53073107,54708,W016,W058,99,0,1
53073117,54708,W016,W121,86,0,1
53073126,54709,W119,W132,95,0,0
53073134,54709,W119,W071,77,0,1
53073142,54709,W119,W144,79,0,0
53073152,54710,W141,W054,91,0,1
53073160,54710,W141,W107,100,0,1
53073190,54712,W011,W103,95,0,1
53073199,54712,W011,W050,82,0,1
53073210,54712,W011,W144,86,0,0
53296402,54756,W067,W035,88,0,1
53296411,54756,W067,W164,79,0,0
53296420,54756,W067,W039,79,0,0
53296463,54760,W098,W075,100,0,1
53296473,54760,W098,W067,97,0,1
53296479,54760,W098,W056,100,0,1
53296490,54761,W099,W164,97,0,0
53296498,54761,W099,W135,76,0,1
53296507,54762,W160,W095,88,0,0
53296514,54762,W160,W154,94,0,0
53296543,54764,W089,W125,88,0,1
53296549,54764,W089,W135,80,0,1
53296559,54764,W089,W039,84,0,0
53296565,54765,W035,W159,75,0,1
53296575,54765,W035,W095,81,0,0
53296581,54765,W035,W062,76,0,1
53296611,54767,W159,W047,91,0,1
53296620,54767,W159,W095,79,0,0
53296627,54768,W062,W047,76,0,1
53296635,54768,W062,W029,84,0,0
53296646,54768,W062,W039,80,0,0
53296653,54769,W056,W047,92,0,1
53296661,54769,W056,W014,94,0,0
53296668,54769,W056,W164,82,0,0
53296677,54770,W017,W099,80,0,1
53296684,54770,W017,W143,75,0,1
53296693,54770,W017,W125,100,0,1
53296700,54771,W100,W125,94,0,1
53296707,54771,W100,W035,98,0,1
53296760,54774,W143,W035,90,0,1
53296770,54774,W143,W017,100,0,1
53296781,54774,W143,W098,75,0,1
53296787,54776,W172,W125,82,0,1
53296798,54776,W172,W095,90,0,0
53296809,54776,W172,W089,88,0,1
53296820,54777,W075,W172,89,0,1
53296828,54777,W075,W089,82,0,1
53296835,54778,W047,W035,96,0,1
53296843,54778,W047,W099,90,0,1
53296851,54778,W047,W009,90,0,0
53296859,54779,W125,W075,81,0,1
53296866,54779,W125,W098,93,0,1
53296876,54779,W125,W143,79,0,1
53296885,54780,W068,W098,85,0,1
53296891,54780,W068,W089,96,0,1
53296899,54780,W068,W075,99,0,1
53296906,54781,W135,W100,90,0,1
53296916,54781,W135,W159,83,0,1
53296922,54781,W135,W125,97,0,1
53333546,53356,W129,W092,85,0,0
53333555,53356,W129,W024,94,0,1
53333562,53358,W024,W060,86,0,1
53333570,53358,W024,W104,78,0,1
53333578,53358,W024,W020,78,0,1
53333587,53359,W148,W067,92,0,1
53333595,53359,W148,W170,100,0,1
53333603,53360,W170,W162,97,0,1
53333612,53360,W170,W173,87,0,0
53333622,53361,W104,W072,83,0,0
53333630,53362,W124,W170,90,0,1
53333638,53362,W124,W129,85,0,1
53333666,53364,W020,W060,78,0,1
53333676,53364,W020,W167,83,0,1
53333683,53364,W020,W162,93,0,1
53333690,53365,W042,W118,86,0,1
53333698,53365,W042,W116,79,0,1
53333708,53366,W015,W042,96,0,1
53333716,53367,W026,W116,89,0,1
53333723,53367,W026,W167,78,0,1
53333750,53369,W116,W124,91,0,1
53333756,53369,W116,W060,80,0,1
53333765,53369,W116,W129,96,0,1
53333771,53370,W060,W024,95,0,1
53333777,53370,W060,W019,97,0,1
53333786,53371,W087,W072,90,0,0
53333793,53371,W087,W020,88,0,1
53333802,53372,W085,W148,94,0,1
53333811,53372,W085,W162,84,0,1
53333820,53372,W085,W065,97,0,1
53333828,53373,W118,W015,81,0,1
53333837,53373,W118,W167,87,0,1
53333844,53374,W162,W170,88,0,1
53333854,53374,W162,W087,96,0,1
53333866,53375,W019,W087,83,0,1
53333876,53376,W069,W173,88,0,0
53333885,53376,W069,W019,88,0,1
53333893,53376,W069,W033,80,0,0
53333930,53379,W065,W129,79,0,1
53333939,53379,W065,W020,90,0,1
53333950,53380,W167,W033,82,0,0
53333959,53380,W167,W020,94,0,1