Thank you all for your valuable insights and feedback so far!
I’m carefully reviewing the points raised, particularly around potential attack vectors, finality concerns, and the feasibility of handling clawbacks at the smart contract level versus the protocol level. These are critical considerations, and I want to ensure all perspectives are thoughtfully addressed.
In the meantime, I encourage you to review the EIP draft - especially the section Hybrid Approach: Combining CeFi & DeFi Security, along with the surrounding discussion on the smart contract alternative and the rationale for a protocol-level approach.
I’ll be compiling a detailed response soon to address each concern individually. For those who haven’t weighed in yet, I’d love to hear your thoughts! Every piece of feedback will be considered as the proposal evolves.
Looking forward to continuing this discussion and refining the best approach together.