Hi @boris, thanks for your comment. Please see my comment in A proposal to move the content in ethereum/wiki to a Wikipedia-style wiki site · Issue #589 · ethereum/wiki · GitHub.
Issues so far:
- No soft wrap in revision history. E.g. in https://en.ethereum.wiki/hist/home, one paragraph appears as one line; and there is no soft wrap option, let alone by default. This doesn’t occur if you edit a page, just in comparing revisions.
- while history for a page is accesible by modifying the link, e.g. https://en.ethereum.wiki/faqs → https://en.ethereum.wiki/hist/faqs, this is not a good UX; there should be a button to access history.
- no sidebar
- not able to search for content in pages
- pages appear to be out of sync, e.g. https://en.ethereum.wiki/edit/famous-bugs and Bugs · ethereum/wiki Wiki · GitHub. Decentralized apps (dapps) · ethereum/wiki Wiki · GitHub is missing (on the WikiJS site). https://en.ethereum.wiki/fundamentals/getting-ether exists, but it was confusing to navigate to https://en.ethereum.wiki/fundamentals (click all pages in the sidebar, then click the arrow in fundamentals), which should probably not be a page. If you don’t click the arrow but just click anywhere else on that Fundamentals line, it will take you to a list of sub pages in the sidebar.
I would probably consider any one of the above issues to be a deal breaker to using the wikiJS site over the GIthub wiki, especially without wikiJS 2.0.
Also, there is no ability yet to watch a page and other features for moderators, but this can’t be considered an issue as Github wikis do not provide this feature yet either, nor have they committed to doing so, while it is planned for WikiJS 2.0.